Choosing a CRM is easier when you start from the work your team does, not from a list of features. This guide takes you through it in eight steps, from deciding whether you need a CRM yet to testing a system with your own work before you sign.
We make Affinux, so we aren’t neutral. The steps work for any system, and where we mention Affinux we say so. If something here is out of date, email support@affinux.com and we’ll correct it.
Step 1: Decide whether you need a CRM yet
A CRM is a shared database of the people your charity works with, such as supporters, volunteers, members and the people you support. Not every charity needs one straight away.
A well-kept spreadsheet can be enough when one or two people look after a short list of contacts. A CRM starts to pay off when:
- several people work with the same people, and each keeps their own list or inbox
- you need consent and Gift Aid records you can rely on
- reports to funders take days to pull together
- the same person is typed into several tools, such as a donor who is also a volunteer
Step 2: Write down the work it has to hold
Before you look at any system, list what your team does each week, in your own words. This is the list you’ll judge every system against.
- Fundraising: donations, Gift Aid, events and supporter journeys
- Delivering services: referrals, cases, sessions, attendance and outcomes
- People who help: volunteers, mentors, carers and trustees
- Members: joining, renewals, training and certificates
- Conversations: email, phone calls, texts, WhatsApp and letters
Most charities do more than one of these. Fundraising CRMs and case management systems are built differently, so the balance matters. Our comparison of UK charity CRMs groups systems by what they’re built for.
Step 3: Work out who will use it, and how
- How many staff will sign in? Many systems price by staff users, so count them.
- Do volunteers need a login? Some systems count them as users. Others give them a portal of their own.
- Should the people you support see anything? Such as their bookings, sessions or invoices.
- Who should see sensitive records? Safeguarding and health information usually needs tighter access than a mailing list.
Step 4: Split your must-haves from your nice-to-haves
Turn steps 2 and 3 into a short list of must-haves: the five to eight things that would make you rule out a system that lacks them. Common ones for UK charities:
- one record for each person, even when they hold several roles, such as volunteer and donor
- consent for each channel and purpose, such as fundraising emails or service update texts
- Gift Aid declarations kept with the right donor
- cases, sessions and outcomes, if you deliver services
- safeguarding concerns that can’t be quietly deleted
- reports for funders and trustees, without rebuilding spreadsheets
- the connections you rely on, such as your mailboxes, website forms and payments
Everything else is a nice-to-have. It can settle a close decision, but it shouldn’t make it.
Step 5: Check how it protects your data
A CRM will hold some of the most sensitive information your charity keeps. Ask every supplier:
- Where is our data stored, and which other companies process it for you?
- Will you sign a contract that covers how you handle our data? The UK GDPR requires a written contract whenever another organisation processes personal data for you. The ICO explains what the contract must include.
- Who can see what? Check roles, teams and restricted records, and whether every read of a sensitive record is logged.
- Can we export everything, at any time, and what happens to our data when we leave?
- Do you hold a security certification, such as Cyber Essentials?
The rules on messages matter too. Marketing emails and texts usually need consent. Charities can also use the charitable purposes soft opt-in, introduced by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, if they meet its conditions. The ICO’s guidance on direct marketing by electronic mail explains both. Check that the system records consent the way you need it.
If you claim Gift Aid, HMRC says most charities must keep declaration records for six years from the end of the accounting period they relate to (Gift Aid declarations). Check the system keeps them, and ask whether it can send claims to HMRC. Our Gift Aid declaration form template lists what each declaration must include.
Step 6: Work out the total cost, not just the licence
Suppliers price in different ways: by staff users, by contacts, by your charity’s income or by the modules you add. Ask each one for a written quote for your size, then add:
- setup and training
- moving your records, if the supplier charges for it
- extra users or contacts as you grow
- messaging and payment charges, such as text messages and card fees
- your own team’s time to set it up and learn it
Our guide to charity CRM pricing has worked first-year budgets. Check the contract length and notice period too. A monthly plan is easier to leave than a contract that runs for years.
Step 7: Plan how your records will move
Ask what will come across and what won’t. Most systems can import people from a spreadsheet, but history such as notes, past donations and attachments is often harder to move. Decide early what you’ll keep in your old system or files as an archive.
If you’re moving to Affinux, read importing your contacts, moving from Lamplight and moving from GoodCRM.
Step 8: Test it with your own work
A demo shows a system at its best. A trial shows how it handles your work. Ask the people who’ll use it every day to try real tasks with made-up records, such as:
- Take a referral or enquiry from a website form, and see where it lands.
- Add someone who holds two roles, such as a volunteer who also donates.
- Log a session or a call, then find it again a week later.
- Record a safeguarding concern, and check who can see it.
- Send a text to people who agreed to texts, and check that it leaves out everyone else.
- Pull together last quarter’s numbers for a funder.
- Export everything to a spreadsheet.
Note where people got stuck. That tells you more than any feature list.
A scoring table you can copy
Give each row a weight from 1 to 3 for how much it matters to you. After each trial, score the system from 0 to 3, multiply by the weight and add up the totals.
| What matters | Weight (1–3) | System A (0–3) | System B (0–3) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Holds the work from step 2 | |||
| Fits how people will use it | |||
| One record per person, with roles | |||
| Consent for each channel and purpose | |||
| Data protection and export | |||
| Total first-year cost | |||
| Moving your records | |||
| How the trial went |
Where Affinux fits
Affinux, a charity CRM with case management built in, is made for charities that deliver services and work with the same people in several roles. It keeps one record for each person, with the casework, conversations and money around it. Stored in the UK, and backed up every night. Plans cost £39, £99 or £249 a month, with no minimum term and a 14-day free trial (Affinux pricing).
Our comparison guide is honest about where another system may suit you better.
Further reading
- The Chartered Institute of Fundraising’s How to pick a CRM: a guide for small charities
- Charity Digital’s best CRM systems for 2026
By the Affinux team. Last updated 13 November 2026.